Citroen C1 Toyota Aygo Peugeot 108 The Citroën C1, Toyota Aygo, and Peugeot 108 are closely related city cars developed through a collaboration between the three manufacturers. They share many components, including engines, platforms, and interiors, but each has distinct styling and minor differences in features. Below is a detailed comparison to help you choose the best option for your needs.
Shared Platform & Engines
- All three cars use the same 1.0-litre three-cylinder petrol engine (68–72 HP), delivering similar performance (0–62 mph in ~14 sec) and fuel economy (~68.9 mpg) 17.
- Previously, the C1 and 108 offered a 1.2-litre engine (82 HP), which provided better acceleration (0–62 mph in 11 sec) but is no longer available in newer models 4.
Running Costs
- Identical fuel efficiency, road tax (£140/year), and low insurance groups (6–9) 19.
- Similar maintenance costs, though Toyota offers a 5-year warranty vs. Citroën/Peugeot’s 3-year coverage 12.
Interior & Tech
- Shared dashboard layout, 7-inch touchscreen, Bluetooth, and smartphone mirroring (Mirror Link/Mirror Screen) 19.
- Lightweight, budget-friendly materials with optional personalization (e.g., colored trims, fabric roofs) 49.
Key Differences
Feature Toyota Aygo Citroën C1 Peugeot 108
Boot Space 168 LITRES 196 LITRES 196 LITRES
Safety 3–4*Euro NCAP (2017) 4* (2014) 4* (2014)
Airbags 4 (6 in top trim) 6 standard 6 standard
Styling Bold “X” design Rounded, playful Chic, Peugeot DNA
Convertible Option No Yes (Airs cape) Yes (TOP!)
Reliability Best(Toyota reputation) Mid-range Mid-range
Which One Should You Choose?
- Toyota Aygo: Best for reliability and resale value, but has a smaller boot and fewer airbags in base models 13.
- Citroën C1: Offers more boot space and a folding fabric roof, but interior quality can feel cheap 47.
- Peugeot 108: A balanced choice with good safety, styling, and warranty (5 years in some markets) 29.
Verdict
- If long-term reliability is key, the Aygo wins 13.
- For practicality (boot space) and fun (convertible), the C1 or 108 are better 49.
Here’s a deeper dive into the Citroën C1, Toyota Aygo, and Peugeot 108, covering performance, ownership costs, driving experience, and long-term reliability to help you make the best choice.
1. Performance & Engines
All three cars share the same 1.0L 3-cylinder petrol engine (68–72 HP), but there are subtle differences:
Model 0–62 mph Top Speed Engine Notes
Toyota Aygo ~14.2 sec ~99 mph Smoother gearbox, slightly better throttle response
Citroën C1 ~14.0 sec ~98 mph Slightly noisier at high RPM
Peugeot 108 ~14.1 sec ~98 mph Best sound insulation
Older models (pre-2018) had an optional 1.2L 4-cylinder (82 HP), which was quicker (~11 sec to 62 mph).
The Toyota Aygo X (2022+) is a completely different SUV-style model—not directly comparable.
Winner: Very close, but the Aygo feels slightly more refined.
2. Fuel Economy & Running Costs
Citroen C1 Toyota Aygo Peugeot 108
Model MPG (Official) Real-World MPG Road Tax (2024) Insurance Group
Toyota Aygo 68.9 mpg ~55–60 mpg £180/year Group 6–9
Citroën C1 68.9 mpg ~50–55 mpg £180/year Group 6–9
Peugeot 108 68.9 mpg ~50–55 mpg £180/year Group 6–9
All three are cheap to run, but the Aygo tends to return slightly better real-world MPG.
Servicing costs are similar, but Toyota offers longer warranty (5 years vs. 3 for C1/108).
Winner: Toyota Aygo (better efficiency + longer warranty).
3. Interior & Comfort
Model Seat Comfort Noise Levels Infotainment Boot Space
Toyota Aygo Firm but supportive Loud at speed Basic 7″ touchscreen 168L (smallest)
Citroën C1 Softer, less support Noisy engine Same as Aygo 196L (best)
Peugeot 108 Best-balanced Quieter cabin Same as Aygo 196L (best)
Peugeot 108 has the best interior finish (softer plastics, better soundproofing).
C1 and 108 have more boot space than the Aygo.
Convertible versions (C1 Airs cape / 108 TOP!) are fun but add weight and reduce rigidity.
Winner: Peugeot 108 (best comfort + practicality).
4. Reliability & Longevity
Model Reliability (What Car?) Common Issues Warranty
Toyota Aygo 
(Best) Minor electrical gremlins 5 years
Citroën C1 (Average) Suspension wear, clutch issues 3 years
Peugeot 108 (Average) Similar to C1 3 years
Aygo is the most reliable (Toyota’s reputation for longevity).
C1 & 108 share parts but have more reported clutch/suspension problems after 60k miles.
Winner: Toyota Aygo (by a big margin).
5. Driving Experience
- Toyota Aygo – Feels the most agile, with slightly sharper steering.
- Citroën C1 – Softest ride, but more body roll in corners.
- Peugeot 108 – Best balance between comfort and handling.
- Best for city driving: All three are great, but the Aygo is slightly more fun.
Best for highways: Peugeot 108 (quieter cabin).
Final Verdict: Which One Should You Buy?
Citroen C1 Toyota Aygo Peugeot 108
Priority Best Choice Why?
Reliability & Resale Value Toyota Aygo Best engine longevity, 5-year warranty.
Practicality (Boot Space) Citroën C1 / Peugeot 108 Bigger boot, folding roof option.
Comfort & Refinement Peugeot 108 Nicer interior, quieter cabin.
Fun & Styling Citroën C1 (Airs cape) Convertible roof, playful design.
Here’s an expanded and detailed comparison of the Citroën C1, Toyota Aygo, and Peugeot 108, covering every critical aspect to help you decide which city car suits your needs best.
1. Design & Styling
- Toyota Aygo: Bold, angular design with an “X” front grille, targeting a youthful audience. Optional decals and vibrant colors add personalization 18.
- Citroën C1: Playful, rounded styling with oversized headlights and LED daytime running lights. Offers a convertible “Airs cape” variant with a folding fabric roof 38.
- Peugeot 108: Sophisticated, with sleek lines and chrome accents.
Verdict:
- Fun & quirky: Aygo.
- Convertible option: C1 or 108.
- Elegance: Peugeot 108.
2. Performance & Engines
- All three share a 1.0L 3-cylinder petrol engine (68–72 HP), but older models (pre-2018) offered a 1.2L (82 HP) in the C1 and 108 for better acceleration (0–62 mph in 11 sec vs. 14 sec for the 1.0L) 1311.
Model 0–62 mph (1.0L) Top Speed Notes
Aygo 14.2 sec 99 mph Sportier exhaust note 8.
C1 14.3 sec 98 mph Smoother ride, noisier engine 3.
108 14.3 sec 98 mph Best sound insulation 5.
Key Differences:
- The 1.2L engine (C1/108 only) is better for highway driving but was discontinued post-2018 311.
- The Aygo’s lighter weight makes it feel slightly more agile 4.
Verdict:
- Best for city driving: All three.
- Highway usability: Older C1/108 with 1.2L engine.
3. Interior & Comfort
Citroen C1 Toyota Aygo Peugeot 108
Feature Toyota Aygo Citroën C1 Peugeot 108
Boot Space 168L (smallest) 1 196L 196L
Rear Legroom Tight for tall adults Slightly better Best of the three
Noise Levels Loud at speed Moderate Quietest cabin
Infotainment 7″ touchscreen (Mirror Link) Same as Aygo Same, but fewer tech options .
Convertible Note:
- The C1 Airs cape and 108 TOP! suffer from wind noise above 20 mph, making them less practical for open-top cruising
Verdict:
- Best interior: Peugeot 108 (refined materials).
- Most practical: C1/108 (larger boot).
4. Reliability & Safety
Reliability:
- Aygo: Top-rated (Toyota’s 5-year warranty; ranked 12th in reliability surveys) 16.
- C1/108: Mid-range (3-year warranty; Citroën ranked 25th in 2018) 111.
Safety:
- Aygo: 3–4 stars (Euro NCAP 2017; 4 stars with Safety Pack) 1.
- C1/108: 4 stars (2014 tests, pre-stricter standards) 16.
- Airbags: C1/108 have 6 standard; Aygo has 4 in base trims 26.
Verdict:
- Best reliability: Aygo.
- Best safety: C1/108 (more airbags).Additional Notes:
- The 1.0L with Stop & Start achieves up to 74.3 mpg in the C1/108 3.
- Resale value: Aygo holds value best due to Toyota’s reputation 6.
Verdict:
- Lowest long-term costs: Aygo (warranty + resale).
- Best warranty: Peugeot 108 (5 years in some markets) 2.
Get article on pdf file….Click now